Most people will not tell their manager they are struggling. The right question, asked consistently, makes it a lot easier for them to.
Ask most managers how their team is doing and they will tell you everyone is fine. Ask the team and the picture is often different. A survey of 2,000 Australians by WayAhead, the Mental Health Association NSW, found that around seven in 10 would not tell their employer about a mental health condition.1,2 Of those, 64 per cent said they would hide it for fear of discrimination, and 38 per cent reported being treated unfairly after disclosing a condition. Only 7 per cent said workplaces always provide a safe environment to ask for help.2
A separate survey by the Corporate Mental Health Alliance Australia found only 56 per cent of employees felt safe to speak about mental health concerns at work.1 When people do not feel safe to raise it, stress stays hidden until it shows up as absence, a resignation, or a claim. The 1:1 is the one regular, private conversation where that can change.
Why the 1:1 is where this gets won or lost
Gallup’s research finds that managers account for at least 70 per cent of the variance in employee engagement scores across business units, and that engagement is highest among employees who have some form of daily communication with their manager.3 The person who sits closest to the work shapes the experience of it more than any company-wide program.
Psychological safety is a concept Harvard’s Amy Edmondson introduced in a 1999 study. It describes a team-wide belief that it is safe to take interpersonal risks.4 Admitting you are unsure or asking for help is one of those risks.5 Google’s Project Aristotle, published in 2015, later found it was the most important factor separating its most effective teams from the rest.6 People judge how safe it is by what happens when someone speaks up, so the first time a team member answers you honestly, your reaction sets the rule for everyone.
It is a compliance question too
Safe Work Australia’s Code of Practice on managing psychosocial hazards covers hazards including job demands, fatigue, low job control, job insecurity, poor support, and lack of role clarity.7 SafeWork SA’s guidance notes that poor support can occur when workers do not receive feedback or have regular performance discussions with their supervisor.8 A regular, well-run 1:1 is one practical way a manager can spot these hazards early. As we covered in our previous article, regulators want to see controls operating in practice, not just written down.
The five questions
You do not need to ask all five every time. Rotate them and let the answer to one lead the conversation. Each maps to a recognised psychosocial hazard, so the answers are useful data and not just chat.
QUESTION 1
What is taking the most energy from you right now?
Hazard it surfaces: job demands and fatigue
Open enough to get past “fine” and specific enough to get a real answer. Listen for long hours, constant urgency, and back-to-back work with no time to recover. Also listen for the opposite: work that is monotonous or under-uses someone’s skills. Low demands are a hazard too.8
QUESTION 2
Where do you have the least say in how your work gets done?
Hazard it surfaces: low job control
Listen for needing sign-off on routine tasks, little say over timing or the order of work, and decisions made about them without them. Guidance on controlling this hazard centres on involving workers in decisions about how they do their work.8
QUESTION 3
What do you need from me or the team that you are not getting right now?
Hazard it surfaces: poor support
Listen for missing information, tools, or feedback, feeling isolated, or having no one to ask. If the answer is “nothing”, try “what would make next month easier?”
QUESTION 4
Is anything about your role, priorities, or what is expected of you unclear or changing?
Hazard it surfaces: lack of role clarity and poor change management
Listen for competing demands from more than one manager, shifting priorities, and changes announced without explanation. People often assume they are the only one who is confused.
QUESTION 5
Is anything about how people are working together making your job harder?
Hazard it surfaces: poor workplace relationships, bullying and harassment
This is the one that matters most. Harassment and bullying were behind 33.2 per cent of serious mental stress claims in Safe Work Australia’s most recent data, ahead of work pressure, as we covered in our previous article.9 People rarely volunteer this, so ask it plainly and calmly, and make clear you want to hear the answer even if it involves a colleague, or you.
What to do when someone opens up
DO
- Thank them for telling you, and reflect back what you heard.
- Ask what would help, then agree on one next step and a date.
AVOID
- Rushing to fix it or reassure (“you’ll be fine”), or minimising what they said.
- Pushing for detail they have not offered, or speculating about a diagnosis. You are a manager, not a clinician.
- Promising confidentiality you cannot keep. Be honest about who you may need to involve.
ESCALATE
- Bullying, harassment, safety risks, or serious wellbeing concerns should follow your organisation’s policy and involve HR.
- If someone may be at immediate risk, treat it as urgent and call 000.
Close the loop
The conversation only works the second time if the first one led somewhere. If someone raises a concern and nothing changes, they will not raise the next one. Follow up on what you agreed, and keep a simple, de-identified note of recurring themes across your team, for example “three people flagged unclear priorities after the restructure”. Patterns let you fix the system instead of only supporting one person, and they give you something concrete to point to if you are ever asked how you manage psychosocial risk.
From one conversation to a team-level view
A 1:1 shows you one person at a time, and only what they feel safe to say. To see patterns across a whole team, including how psychologically safe people feel, you need to measure it. That is what Team Excel is designed to do: give leaders a data-backed view of how their team is working together, so the conversations in your 1:1s are informed by more than gut feel.
Want to see how psychologically safe your own teams feel? Book a free 15-minute chat with our team.
If you or someone in your team needs support, Lifeline is on 13 11 14 and Beyond Blue is on 1300 22 4636. In an emergency, call 000.
Sources
- HR Leader, “7 in 10 reluctant to share mental health status with boss” (reporting WayAhead and Corporate Mental Health Alliance Australia surveys). https://www.hrleader.com.au/people/24640-7-in-10-reluctant-to-share-mental-health-status-with-boss
- AHRI, “Most Australians would hide a mental health condition from their employer”. https://www.ahri.com.au/articles/australians-hide-mental-health-condition-from-employer
- Gallup, Harter, J. and Adkins, A., “Employees Want a Lot More From Their Managers”. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/236570/managers-account-variance-team-engagement.aspx
- Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350-383.
- Harvard Business School, Working Knowledge, “Four steps to build the psychological safety that high-performing teams need today”. https://www.library.hbs.edu/working-knowledge/four-steps-to-build-the-psychological-safety-that-high-performing-teams-need-today
- Google re:Work, Project Aristotle (published 2015). https://rework.withgoogle.com/
- Safe Work Australia, Managing Psychosocial Hazards at Work Code of Practice (February 2026 edition, as published by SafeWork SA). https://safework.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0020/1238123/Managing-Psychosocial-Hazards-at-Work-Code-of-Practice-February-2026.pdf
- SafeWork SA, Psychosocial risk assessment guidance. https://safework.sa.gov.au/workplaces/mentally-healthy-workplaces/psychosocial-risk-assessment
- Safe Work Australia, Key Work Health and Safety Statistics Australia 2025 (also cited in our previous article).
This article is general information, not legal, medical, or clinical advice. Survey figures are as reported by the sources above and should be checked against the originals before publication. Obligations vary by state and territory.
